The preliminary examiners will have four weeks to submit, either jointly or separately, a written reasoned statement on the dissertation. The Faculty Doctoral Student Services will forward the statements received to the doctoral candidate and other necessary parties.
In their statements, the preliminary examiners must pay attention to at least the following matters:
- The significance and status of the research within the research field
- The scope of the dissertation and the sufficiency of the material, the significance of the content and deficiencies of the manuscripts submitted for publication
- The application and development of the research methods
- The derivation of the results from the material studied
- The consistency of the structure of the work
- Familiarity with and use of the literature
- The composition of the dissertation (presentation, style and language)
- Sufficiency of the doctoral candidate’s own research contribution (if the dissertation contains co-authored articles): whether the author has contributed sufficiently to the dissertation as a whole
If they so wish, the doctoral candidate has the right to submit an objection to the preliminary examination statements before the Faculty Council processes them.